Nancy: Demokratie und Aristokratie - Philosophy@WorkPhilosophy@Work

„Die Demokratie ist egalitäre Aristokratie.“ (p. 68) #Nancy #Demokratie #Aristokratie

%7B%22status%22%3A%22success%22%2C%22updateneeded%22%3Afalse%2C%22instance%22%3A%22zotpress-439424e34323a0fb86d80fe01484e351%22%2C%22meta%22%3A%7B%22request_last%22%3A0%2C%22request_next%22%3A0%2C%22used_cache%22%3Atrue%7D%2C%22data%22%3A%5B%7B%22key%22%3A%22S7E27XP5%22%2C%22library%22%3A%7B%22id%22%3A2012693%7D%2C%22meta%22%3A%7B%22creatorSummary%22%3A%22Nancy%22%2C%22parsedDate%22%3A%222009%22%2C%22numChildren%22%3A1%7D%2C%22bib%22%3A%22%3Cdiv%20class%3D%5C%22csl-bib-body%5C%22%20style%3D%5C%22line-height%3A%201.35%3B%20padding-left%3A%201em%3B%20text-indent%3A-1em%3B%5C%22%3E%5Cn%20%20%3Cdiv%20class%3D%5C%22csl-entry%5C%22%3E%3Cspan%20style%3D%5C%22font-variant%3Asmall-caps%3B%5C%22%3ENancy%2C%20Jean-Luc%3C%5C%2Fspan%3E%2C%20%3Ci%3EWahrheit%20der%20Demokratie.%20Ein%20Werk%20%26%23xFC%3Bber%20Demokratie%20als%20Revolution%20in%20der%20Schwebe%20%26%23x2013%3B%20und%20ein%20Aufruf%2C%20Partizipation%20zu%20erk%26%23xE4%3Bmpfen%3C%5C%2Fi%3E.%20Wien%3A%20Passagen%20Verlag%202009.%3C%5C%2Fdiv%3E%5Cn%3C%5C%2Fdiv%3E%22%2C%22data%22%3A%7B%22itemType%22%3A%22book%22%2C%22title%22%3A%22Wahrheit%20der%20Demokratie.%20Ein%20Werk%20%5Cu00fcber%20Demokratie%20als%20Revolution%20in%20der%20Schwebe%20%5Cu2013%20und%20ein%20Aufruf%2C%20Partizipation%20zu%20erk%5Cu00e4mpfen%22%2C%22creators%22%3A%5B%7B%22creatorType%22%3A%22author%22%2C%22firstName%22%3A%22Jean-Luc%22%2C%22lastName%22%3A%22Nancy%22%7D%5D%2C%22abstractNote%22%3A%221%5CnDie%20Wahrheit%20der%20Demokratie%20ist%20diese%3A%20Sie%20ist%20%5Cu2013%20im%20Gegensatz%20zu%20dem%2C%20was%20sie%20f%5Cu00fcr%20die%20Alten%20war%20%5Cu2013%20keine%20politische%20Form%20unter%20anderen.%20Sie%20ist%20gar%20keine%20politische%20Form%2C%20oder%20aber%20und%20zumindest%20ist%20sie%20nicht%20vor%20allem%20eine%20politische%20Form.%20F%5Cu00fcr%20Jacques%20Derrida%20ist%20er%20schlicht%20und%20ergreifend%20der%20gr%5Cu00f6%5Cu00dfte%20zeitgen%5Cu00f6ssische%20Denker%20des%20Ber%5Cu00fchrens%2C%20dem%20er%20einen%20ganzen%20Band%20seines%20betr%5Cu00e4chtlichen%20Werkes%20widmete%20und%20dessen%20Name%20schon%20den%20Titel%20ziert%20%28Derrida%2C%20Ber%5Cu00fchren%2C%20Jean-Luc%20Nancy%20.%20Berlin%202007%29.%20Nancys%20Corpus%20%28Berlin%202003%29%2C%20also%20nicht%20sein%20eigener%20leibhaftiger%2C%20eher%20eine%20vorsichtige%20Ann%5Cu00e4herung%20an%20eine%20K%5Cu00f6rperphilosophie%2C%20welche%20in%20zahlreiche%20Sprachen%20%5Cu00fcbersetzt%20und%20zum%20Teil%20leidenschaftlich%20diskutiert%20wurde.%20Die%20Regisseurin%20Sofia%20Coppola%20d%5Cu00fcrfte%20sich%20f%5Cu00fcr%20ihren%20Film%20The%20Virgin%20Suicides%20%28USA%201999%2C%20deutsch%3A%20Das%20Geheimnis%20ihres%20Todes%29%20von%20ihm%20inspiriert%20haben%20lassen%2C%20die%20Filmmusik%20des%20franz%5Cu00f6sischen%20Duos%20Air%20gibt%20den%20Szenen%20zum%20Teil%20eine%20groteske%20Stimmung.%20Das%20Buch%20von%20Nancy%20singul%5Cu00e4r%20plural%20sein%20%28Berlin%202004%29%20schlie%5Cu00dft%20dagegen%20einen%20fehlenden%20Link%20der%20Dekonstruktivisten%2C%20falls%20es%20diese%20gibt%20%28neben%20Derrida%2C%20Philippe%20Lacoue-Labarthe%20wurde%20immer%20wieder%20Nancy%20mit%20ihnen%20in%20Verbindung%20gebracht%29.%20Dieser%20entwickelt%20das%20Denken%20der%20Differenz%20%28sexueller%2C%20ethnischer%2C%20kultureller%20etc.%29%20hin%20zur%20Gemeinschaft%2C%20des%20gemeinsamen%20bzw.%20desIn-Gemeinschaft-Sein%20%2C%20was%20er%20aber%20ausdr%5Cu00fccklich%20au%5Cu00dferhalb%20der%20Arbeitswelt%20angesiedelt%20haben%20m%5Cu00f6chte.%20Nun%20also%20eine%20aktuellere%20Arbeit%20des%20Strasbourger%20Philosophen%20%5Cu00fcber%20die%20Wahrheit%20der%20Demokratie%20%2C%20welche%20die%201968er-Bewegung%20thematisiert.%5CnZun%5Cu00e4chst%20greift%20er%20die%20schlechten%20Debatten%20zum%20vierzigsten%20Jahrestag%20in%20Frankreich%20auf%2C%20in%20denen%20auch%20vom%20amtierenden%20Staatspr%5Cu00e4sidenten%20von%20Sittenverfall%20und%20moralischem%20Relativismus%20schwadroniert%20wurde.%20Es%20gebe%20keinen%20Grund%20von%20einem%20%5Cu201eErbe%5Cu201c%20von%2068%20zu%20sprechen%2C%20sein%20Geist%20w%5Cu00e4re%20immer%20noch%20agil%20und%20abenteuerlustig.%20%5Cu201eEs%20gibt%20kein%20Erbe%2C%20es%20gab%20keinen%20Todesfall.%20Der%20Geist%20hat%20nicht%20aufgeh%5Cu00f6rt%20zu%20wehen%5Cu201c%20%28S.%2016%29.%20Es%20gibt%20also%20auch%20nichts%20auszuschlagen.%20Die%20damalige%20Zeit%20des%20Kalten%20Krieges%20habe%20nicht%20gemerkt%2C%20wie%20sie%20unmerklich%20gegen%20sich%20selbst%20in%20R%5Cu00fcckstand%20geriet%2C%20die%20dr%5Cu00fcckende%20Stimmung%20in%20Deutschland%20der%20sechziger%20Jahre%20%28in%20der%20zum%20Beispiel%20Frauen%20bis%20in%20die%201970er%20Jahre%20hinein%20ohne%20Zustimmung%20des%20Ehegatten%20weder%20ein%20Konto%20er%5Cu00f6ffnen%2C%20noch%20berufst%5Cu00e4tig%20sein%20konnten%29%2C%20die%20R%5Cu00fcckst%5Cu00e4ndigkeiten%20in%20Frankreich%2C%20die%20Verbissenheit%20der%20USA%20in%20Vietnam%20und%20so%20weiter%2C%20all%20diese%20Faktoren%20wollten%20nicht%20wahrhaben%2C%20dass%20neue%20politische%20Formen%20erprobt%20wurden%20-%20R%5Cu00e4te%20oder%20Selbstverwaltungen%2C%20direkte%20Demokratien%20und%20Teilhabe.%20W%5Cu00f6rter%20wie%20Kommunismus%20oder%20Sozialismus%20h%5Cu00e4tten%20nicht%20zuf%5Cu00e4llig%2C%20abgesehen%20von%20manchen%20Verdrehungen%20denen%20sie%20unterworfen%20waren%2C%20den%20Anspruch%20gen%5Cu00e4hrt%2C%20den%20die%20Demokratie%20nicht%20mehr%20erf%5Cu00fcllen%20konnte.%20Nun%20n%5Cu00e4hert%20sich%20der%20Philosoph%2C%20wohl%20bewusst%20kontr%5Cu00e4r%20zu%20KollegInnen%20seines%20Berufstandes%2C%20der%20Politik.%20%5Cu201eAlles%20ist%20politisch%5Cu201c%2C%20die%20Maxime%20der%201968er%20h%5Cu00e4lt%20er%20allerdings%20f%5Cu00fcr%20eine%20neotheologische%20Floskel%2C%20wir%20br%5Cu00e4uchten%20also%20Pascal%2C%20Rousseau%20mit%20Marx.%20Warum%3F%20Weil%20die%20Demokratien%20heute%20mehr%20denn%20je%20durch%20Plutokratien%2C%20Technokratien%20und%20Mafiokratien%20bedroht%20seien.%5Cn%5Cu201eDie%20Demokratie%20fordert%20tats%5Cu00e4chlich%20eine%20Revolution%2C%20n%5Cu00e4mlich%20die%20Basis%20der%20Politik%20selbst%20umzudrehen.%20Sie%20muss%20sie%20der%20Abwesenheit%20einer%20Grundlage%20aussetzen.%20Doch%20sie%20erlaubt%20damit%20nicht%2C%20dass%20die%20Revolution%20bis%20zur%20vorausgesetzten%20Grundlage%20zur%5Cu00fcckkehrt.%20Eine%20Revolution%20in%20der%20Schwebe%20also%5Cu201c%20%28S.%2081%2C%20Hervorh.%20i.O.%29.%5CnEs%20seien%20gerade%20in%20letzter%20Zeit%20verschiedene%20M%5Cu00f6glichkeiten%20eines%20solchen%20Denkens%20erprobt%20worden%2C%20des%20fortw%5Cu00e4hrenden%20Kleinkrieges%20gegen%20den%20Staat%20im%20Gegensatz%20zur%20Macht%5Cu00fcbernahme%20durch%20einen%20Umsturz%2C%20die%20%5Cu201epermanente%20Revolution%5Cu201c%2C%20die%20der%20Autor%20richtig%20findet.%20Er%20nennt%20sie%20zwar%20nicht%20ausdr%5Cu00fccklich%2C%20aber%20man%20m%5Cu00fcsste%20blind%20und%20taub%20sein%2C%20wenn%20einem%20da%20nicht%20verschiedene%20Bewegungen%20in%20Lateinamerika%20und%20anderswo%20in%20den%20Sinn%20kommen%20w%5Cu00fcrden.%20Der%20Text%20ist%20eine%20Aufforderung%2C%20die%20Demokratien%20daran%20zu%20messen%2C%20was%20sie%20vorgeben%20zu%20sein%2C%20dann%20weiterzugehen%2C%20um%20mehr%20partizipative%20Demokratie%20zu%20ringen%2C%20ohne%20dabei%20stehen%20zu%20bleiben%20und%20auch%20Bereiche%20wie%20Kunst%2C%20Malerei%20und%20Film%20mit%20einzubeziehen.%20Diese%20Bereiche%20politisch%20neu%20zu%20denken%20seien%20eine%20politische%20Notwendigkeit.%5CnEin%20Text%20der%20Mut%20machen%20m%5Cu00f6chte%20es%20zu%20probieren%2C%20noch%20einmal%20zu%20versuchen%2C%20vielleicht%20das%20furiose%20kommunistisch-libert%5Cu00e4re%20Manifest%20unserer%20Tage%21%5Cn%2A%2A%5CnDie%20Rezension%20erschien%20zuerst%20im%20November%202009%20auf%20stattweb.de%20%28Update%3A%20kritisch-lesen.de%2C%20ast%2C%2012%5C%2F2010%29%22%2C%22date%22%3A%222009%22%2C%22language%22%3A%22%22%2C%22ISBN%22%3A%22%22%2C%22url%22%3A%22%22%2C%22collections%22%3A%5B%2296IMF5ZE%22%2C%22AIMAEH3D%22%2C%22LGZWLYMM%22%5D%2C%22dateModified%22%3A%222019-02-11T13%3A20%3A47Z%22%7D%7D%5D%7D

Nancy, Jean-Luc, Wahrheit der Demokratie. Ein Werk über Demokratie als Revolution in der Schwebe – und ein Aufruf, Partizipation zu erkämpfen. Wien: Passagen Verlag 2009.

Related Posts